Mel Clifford

Culture Isn't a Department

Mel Clifford smiling with his chin resting on his hand

When we talk about organisational culture, who actually creates it?

I’ve noticed that culture has become one of those words that appears in almost every conversation about organisations.

We talk about building a great culture.

Creating a positive culture.

Developing a high-performance culture.

Creating a culture of innovation, collaboration, accountability, inclusion and any number of other things.

And, of course, there’s usually a department somewhere called People & Culture.

But I’ve been thinking about something.

Can you really create a great culture by giving responsibility for it to a department?

I don’t think so.

In fact, I think that’s one of the biggest misunderstandings organisations have about culture.

Culture isn’t something you can put on a wall

Most organisations have a set of values.

They’ve probably spent a considerable amount of time developing them, discussing them and deciding which words best describe the organisation they want to be.

Integrity.

Respect.

Teamwork.

Innovation.

Trust.

Customer focus.

All perfectly reasonable things to aspire to.

And then they print them on posters, put them on the website and include them in presentations.

Nothing wrong with that.

But here’s the problem.

Having values and actually living them are two very different things.

I’ve seen organisations talk about respect while tolerating managers who treat people badly.

I’ve seen organisations promote teamwork while rewarding individual performance at the expense of everyone else.

I’ve seen organisations talk about innovation while making it almost impossible for anyone to challenge the way things have always been done.

And I’ve seen organisations talk about trust while introducing processes that suggest they don’t trust their employees at all.

You get the picture.

The words say one thing.

The behaviour says another.

And people notice.

They always do.

Culture is created every day

Here’s what I believe.

Culture isn’t created during an annual strategy meeting.

It isn’t created by a consultant who produces a rather impressive presentation.

And it certainly isn’t created by putting a new set of values on the wall.

Culture is created through the everyday behaviour of the people who work in an organisation.

It’s how managers treat their teams.

It’s how colleagues treat each other.

It’s how decisions are made.

It’s how mistakes are handled.

It’s whether people feel comfortable speaking up.

It’s whether someone gets thanked for doing a good job.

It’s whether people are treated fairly when things go wrong.

And it’s what happens when nobody from senior management is watching.

Because that’s when you often discover what the culture is really like.

You can tell people that your organisation values honesty, but what happens when someone points out that a senior manager has made a mistake?

You can say that you encourage innovation, but what happens when somebody suggests an idea that challenges the established way of doing things?

You can talk about respect, but what happens when a manager consistently behaves in a disrespectful way?

Those moments tell you far more about an organisation’s culture than any number of posters or presentations.

Everyone has a part to play

I think this is where we need to be a little careful.

It’s easy to say that culture is the responsibility of the CEO.

And certainly, the CEO has an enormous influence.

The CEO sets the tone, establishes expectations and demonstrates through their own behaviour what is acceptable.

But culture doesn’t belong exclusively to the CEO either.

Managers have a responsibility to create an environment in which their teams can do their best work.

They need to listen, communicate, support people, deal with problems and treat everyone fairly.

Employees have a responsibility too.

How we treat our colleagues matters.

Whether we share information, offer help, show respect and take responsibility for our own behaviour all contribute to the working environment.

And the same applies to everyone, regardless of their position in the organisation.

You don’t need to be a senior manager to influence culture.

Sometimes the person who makes the biggest difference to someone’s working day is simply the colleague who takes the time to listen, offers a helping hand or makes an effort to include them.

Those things matter.

And they happen every day.

Culture is not something an organisation has. It’s something its people create.

What happens when the values are challenged?

Here’s an interesting test.

Imagine an organisation that proudly promotes respect as one of its core values.

One of its senior managers consistently behaves badly towards their team.

Employees complain.

The issue is raised with HR.

But nothing happens because the manager delivers excellent financial results and is considered too important to the business.

What message does that send?

Quite a clear one, I would suggest.

It tells everyone that respect is important, unless the person behaving disrespectfully happens to be commercially valuable.

And that’s the problem.

Values are only meaningful when they’re applied consistently.

It’s relatively easy to demonstrate integrity when everything is going well.

It’s rather more difficult when doing the right thing might involve a difficult conversation, an unpopular decision or admitting that someone in a senior position has got things wrong.

But that’s precisely when values matter most.

If you only live your values when it’s convenient, they’re not really values at all.

They’re aspirations.

And there’s a difference.

So, how do you create a great culture?

I don’t think there’s a magic formula.

But I do think it starts with a few straightforward things.

Be clear about the behaviours you expect.

Make sure leaders demonstrate those behaviours themselves.

Support managers to become better managers.

Listen to employees, and do something with what they tell you.

Recognise good behaviour, not just good financial results.

Deal with behaviour that doesn’t reflect the organisation’s values, regardless of someone’s seniority or position.

And perhaps most importantly, make sure that what you say and what you do are consistent.

It’s not particularly complicated.

But it does require commitment.

And it requires everyone to understand that they have a part to play.

You can’t simply announce that you’re changing the culture and expect everyone to fall into line.

Culture develops through the choices we make and the way we behave, day after day.

It’s built one conversation, one decision and one interaction at a time.

The question I always ask

I think organisations sometimes spend far too much time talking about the culture they want and not nearly enough time looking at the culture they actually have.

The two can be very different.

And perhaps the best way to find out is to ask the people who experience it every day.

Not just the senior management team.

Not just the HR department.

Everyone.

Because if you want to understand your culture, don’t just look at the values on the wall.

Look at how people behave when they’re working together.

Look at how managers treat their teams.

Look at how decisions are made.

And look at what happens when someone does something that challenges the organisation’s stated values.

That will tell you a great deal.

So here’s my question for you this week:

If someone asked the people who work in your organisation to describe its culture, would their answer match the values you’ve proudly displayed on your walls?

It’s worth asking.

And perhaps it’s even more important to be prepared to listen to the answer.

— Mel

Portrait of Mel Clifford with silver hair, round black glasses and a tweed waistcoat

Mel Clifford

Author, speaker and consultant. Fifty years of working with people, and still fascinated by what makes us tick.

Mel’s weekly note

Stay in the conversation.

One thoughtful email from Mel each week — a new Journal entry, a story, an observation, now and then a poem.

Keep reading

More from the Journal.

Culture Isn’t a Department

When we talk about organisational culture, who actually creates it? I’ve noticed that culture has become one of those words […]

Read

Who Is Really Responsible for Your People?

If people really are an organisation’s greatest asset, who is responsible for looking after them? I want to explore something […]

Read

Changing the Label on the Door

Great organisations are built on people. But does changing the name of the department responsible for them actually make any […]

Read